301.519.9237 exdirector@nesaus.org

3.6.20 – SSI

Once primarily focused on military and critical infrastructure installations, the thermal camera market is far more expansive these days. Industry authorities explain where opportunity lies.

The varied types of applications suitable for thermal imaging nowadays can be nothing short of head-scratching. Technological advances have led to a decrease in unit size and far more affordable price points than just a handful of years ago when thermal cameras were mostly exclusive to the military and critical infrastructure.

Today’s smaller form factors and advancements in image processing allow for mainstream applications such as residential and small businesses, where thermal imagers are being used for leak detection (water, gas or air) to locating insufficient insulation.

Manufacturers are releasing cameras designed for outdoor perimeter security cameras for the commercial market that integrate both thermal sensors and visible light imagers for verification. Still other models commonly incorporate onboard analytics to notify operators of critical events.

SSI conversed with several subject matter experts from leading manufacturers to learn about the diverse applications for thermal technology, along with readily available marketing tips and vertical market opportunities for installing security contractors to pursue.

Midmarket & SMB Opportunities

Wide-ranging retail and commercial settings are prime examples of market niches opening up to thermal imaging due to cost-effective solutions that provide detection under all different types of circumstances, explains Ryan Zatolokin, senior technologist, North America, at Axis Communications.

“Essentially the whole point of a thermal camera is to do detection, and with analytics we can do more precise detection by filtering out details that we don’t want,” he says.

In the banking sector, consider a vestibule or an area around an ATM where there may not be a lot of light. A thermal camera will detect people approaching the ATM. By applying analytics you can then mark perimeter areas within the scene to monitor and create alerts.

“You can see the contrast between a human being and the background, so especially in situations where there is very low light — or no light in some circumstances — thermal cameras are not affected by that at all,” Zatolokin says.

Aaron Saks, product and technical manager for Hanwha Techwin America, explains thermal cameras are being utilized cost effectively by small manufacturing companies that need to monitor their equipment, furnaces or production lines.

“Thermal cameras used to be priced out of the realm of the small and medium-sized business [SMB]; however, now they‘re affordable and can be used in places where life-safety demands monitoring and notification,” he says.

There are many industrial applications where machinery needs to be maintained. Thermal cameras can provide warning that operations are not normal and keep an eye on the temperature of pipes, battery packs and more. The use cases don’t stop there.

“Small businesses that have expensive fleets can use thermal cameras to ensure protection of their perimeter. Zoos and nature preserves can monitor the wildlife without disturbing them with IR illuminators,” Saks explains.

Jennifer Hackenburg, senior product marketing manager for Dahua Technology USA, hits on an application example that has particular global relevance, especially in the wake of the recent the coronavirus outbreak.

Dairy farmers use thermal cameras to monitor the body temperature of pregnant cows to gauge when they go into labor.

“Medical centers, hospitals, airports and railway terminals have become emerging applications for thermal cameras. A thermal camera with temperature control can be used to measure people’s temperatures and spot fevers without using intrusive devices,” she says. “This remote way of monitoring potential signs of infection reduces the risk of further contamination.”

Transportation hubs and other facilities concerned with customs and border protection can use thermal imaging to screen passengers and immediately route those with the abnormal temperatures to special care, Hackenburg continues. The quick mass-screening also mitigates delays and discomfort to passengers.

Consider yet another unique market niche cited by Hackenburg leveraging the technology: dairy farms. Farmers use thermal cameras to monitor the body temperature of pregnant cows to gauge when they go into labor.

“With numerous cows at different stages of gestation, it’s challenging to monitor each and every cow at all hours of the day and night,” she says. “With a thermal thermometry camera, when a cow goes into labor the animal’s temperature increases resulting in an alarm and reducing manpower to monitor the cows throughout the night.”

Datacenters have become a huge market, says Tony DeStefano, a distribution sales manager at Hikvision USA. He applies the term “data-center” loosely, encompassing server rooms or network closets. Suffice to say nearly every business has some version of any one of those that needs to be closely monitored.

“By sensing and sending alerts about anomalies in temperature, thermal cameras can prevent fires, the malfunction or loss of data and storage equipment, and help owners schedule preventative maintenance,” he explains. “It’s important to note that damage to a datacenter of any size can cripple a business, and it’s the kind of loss that many businesses cannot recover from. There is very real ROI for business owners who invest in thermal cameras.”

As end users well know, he continues, the cost of data loss or excessive downtime can be catastrophic. “One question I suggest that integrators ask their end user is: How do you protect your servers?”

Across the security industry, customers are continuing to recognize the value of thermal imaging in enabling video capture in harsh conditions such as in total darkness and through fog, sun glare and smoke, says Fredrik Wallberg, director of marketing for security, FLIR Systems.

“At a high level, we’ve seen the greatest adoption among organizations that store highly valuable, expensive assets outdoors. Common examples include sites with small- or medium-size perimeters such as substations, marinas, stadiums, construction locations and parking garages,” he says. “For these entities, cameras with short detection ranges that yield wide area monitoring are sufficient.”

Wallberg also notes emerging interest in thermal payloads on drones. Similar to the thermal market, there are a variety of drone options in the unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) market, from military-grade drones to drones available for commercial or personal use.

“We’re also seeing greater integration of thermal cameras with radar solutions to improve long-range detection and target tracking. This integrated solution generates cost savings for customers who may have considered solutions that require more infrastructure like buried sensor cables,” Wallberg says. “The effectiveness and cost efficiency of thermal-radar solutions make them another viable option for the SMB market.”

The top scene compares an IR-illuminated camera image of a man in the bushes with a thermal security camera image of the same setting.

Necessary Skillsets & Other Know-How

Installing security contractors practiced in the design and deployment of IP video surveillance solutions are well-suited to adopt thermal imaging into their portfolio of services. While there are technical nuances that will require training, most manufacturers offer more than sufficient support to their reseller partners. Saks suggests a main factor to keep in mind is the lensing. Many years ago, security system designers would use lens wheels to calculate view angles.

Now with low-cost varifocal cameras, multisensors and ultra-wide angle lenses, things have been made so much easier, he says. Another key issue, Saks explains, is to understand that thermal cameras measure radiated heat to represent surface temperature. The thermal properties of various objects, known as its emissivity, can change the look or measured temperature reading.

“It is important to understand the objects and their emissivity if you want to measure their temperature with a radiometric camera, such as machinery or manufacturing equipment,” he says. Hackenburg advises that installing security contractors should identify the compatibility of the thermal camera with the VMS and recording device. This is imperative when it comes to deploying analytics and triggering alarms. She also suggests dealers and integrators become familiar with bi-spectral cameras to expand their portfolio and deployment potential. These models are essentially two cameras integrated into a single housing. One side features a thermal sensor for detection and the other side offers a visible color sensor for identification.“

A thermal camera sees heat, not light. If an end user needs to be able to match up a person’s identity or the color of a vehicle based on the heat signature, a dual-head camera — known as a bi-spectrum or bi-spectral camera — or a separate visible light camera will be required,” she explains.

The technical training for deployment of the cameras is pretty straightforward, DeStefano says, involving alarm temperature setting as well as proper camera positioning and focusing. “Dealers and integrators will benefit from some training to understand the potential use cases, and they’ll need additional training for the project design and deployment of thermal cameras. Manufacturers provide training for both,” he continues.

Wallberg also emphasizes security dealers and integrators have a knowledgeable understanding of thermal cameras, the factors that determine thermal camera selection, and the deployment best practices that optimize performance. “FLIR offers thermal 101 courses, guide-books, best practices white papers, and online trainings for security professionals to aid in thermal education, camera selection and configuration, analytics setup, etc.,” he says.

Above all, don’t shy away from learning about thermal technology because you are leery or afraid of it, Zatolokin advises. “You can do amazing things with thermal cameras. But also it’s about understanding the technology and not making assumptions on what it can do,” he says. “Once you understand the technology, it opens up a whole new world of possibilities in terms of detection. It’s about understanding and setting the proper expectations with your customers. You’ll be very successful if you do that correctly.”

Hot Tips to Heat Up Thermal Sales

Not long ago most any thermal camera cost thousands of dollars; hence, end users logically assume price points remain exceedingly high. Thus it makes sense for the affordability of thermal imaging to remain a key topic for dealers and integrators to address.

But as widespread adoption of the technology increasingly spans myriad market niches and applications, there is much more to discuss with potential clientele. Our subject matter experts offer advice and topical suggestions that installing security contractors can emphasize during a sales conversation.

▶ The most important thing is to identify the use case for what information the integrator wants to provide the end user. Thermals are very good for detection. They’re not good for things like identification. So having a good idea of the use case and what the technology is capable of. I’ve had end users tell me that they wanted to see through the trunks of cars, which you cannot do with the thermal camera. — Ryan Zatolokin, Axis Communications

▶ An important question to ask is whether the customer wants to detect activity that regular cameras haven’t been able to see. There are some applications where low-light surveillance cameras are not adequate in detecting humans: smoke, haze, fog, thick brush, or complete darkness, for example.— Jennifer Hackenburg, Dahua Technology USA

▶ There are many factors that affect the performance and success of a thermal camera deployment. Determining camera placement, selecting which lens to use, choosing field of views, installing cameras to run in parallel with fixed cameras, identifying your dead zones, setting up slew-to-cue functions, and configuring analytics are all important steps in the installation process. As an integrator, set yourself apart from competitors by educating yourself on thermal camera deployment. — Fredrik Wallberg, FLIR Systems

▶ Thermal cameras can provide excellent visual details for long-range fence line detection and other similar use cases, but it is important to educate the end user as to what a thermal camera is and what the video will look like. They need to understand that they can tell when a person is present, but they will not be able to identify who that person is. — Aaron Saks, Hanwha Techwin America

▶ The best thing a dealer or integrator can do is get their hands on a thermal camera with onboard analytics and test the camera in your own facility. Once integrators see the thermal cameras’ capabilities, they can take it to their customers and show how thermal cameras can reduce the risk of operational failures and improve the security of their facility. My advice is plain and simple: Listen to your customers’ problems and just get creative. — Tony DeStefano, Hikvision USA